Webinar Atas Permintaan

The Future of Refining: Survive, Thrive, or Retreat?

Webinar originally recorded on 11/17/2026

Penganalisis

Penganalisis Utama

For decades, refineries have played a clear role in the energy and chemical system: converting crude oil into fuels, petrochemical feedstocks, and other essential products. That role is now being challenged from multiple directions. Demand for core products declines, newer integrated assets erode competitiveness, crude supply becomes less reliable, energy costs make production uneconomic, and carbon costs undermine the license to operate. For refinery majors, the question is no longer only how to optimize today’s asset base, but how to prepare for multiple futures in which the traditional refinery model comes under structural pressure.

This webinar introduces a scenario-based framework for evaluating the strategic options available to refinery majors. We examine how companies can respond across five potential disruptions through three strategic postures: survive, thrive, or retreat. The session maps these postures to enabling technology pathways — from operational efficiency and crude flexibility to biorefining, petrochemicals integration, electrified refining, carbon utilization, and asset repurposing — and highlights how leaders can distinguish no-regret technology options from more situational bets.

Runeel Daliah: Hello, everyone, and welcome to the webinar, The Future of Refining: Survive, Thrive, or Retreat. My name is Runeel Daliah, Principal Analyst here at Lux Research, and I will be presenting and moderating today’s session. And presenting alongside with me today is my colleague Cansu Doganay, Analyst here at Lux Research. Throughout the sessions, you can type in any questions you have in the question box on your screen. We will answer all of the questions that we can. And if your question does not get answered, please don’t hesitate to e-mail it to [email protected] and we will respond. But before we start the webinar, a word about who we are. At Lux Research, we help organizations make more confident innovation decisions about what matters next. And as an independent research advisory firm, we work with many of the world’s leading companies to identify emerging opportunities, evaluate technologies, and make high-impact innovation decisions. Our scientists, our engineers, analysts, and industry experts combine original research and methodologies with practical decision frameworks to help organizations separate signal from the noise. And today’s webinar is an opportunity to share some of that thinking with you. Without any further ado, let’s jump into the session. So what we want to discuss here is the future of refining. Today we live in very uncertain times and whether you’re an oil and gas company, whether you’re a chemical or whether you’re a steel company, for example, you have to be able to survive in those uncertain times. And what we want to do here today is take a look at the concept of resiliency and how it applies to an industrial player, in this case the oil and gas sector. But before we jump into the topic, I want to play a guessing game. Does anyone who’s watching this right now, does anyone know who this man is? This man is Gerrit Wagner, the former CEO of Shell back in the 1970s. And if you had to guess, what would have been his biggest worry back then? His biggest worry would probably have been the OPEC oil embargo. When back then, due to tensions in the Middle East, the OPEC organization announced an embargo against the Netherlands, which means that the Netherlands did not have enough crude oil to refine, and that led to a shortage of diesel and gasoline in the country. And while in the picture here, you can see what Dutch people do when they are not allowed to drive cars anymore, they have a picnic on the highway. Let’s move on to the next one. Anyone know who this man is? This man is Clifton Garvin, the former CEO of ExxonMobil, also in the 1970s. He also had the OPEC oil crisis to deal with, but then is there another crisis that also happened during his time? And that crisis is the Venezuelan crisis, where in 1975, Venezuela decided to nationalize its oil sector, which means that every foreign oil and gas company at the time, including Exxon, were forced to sell the refineries to the Venezuelan government. Let’s move on. Let’s go further in time. This is William Klesse, the former CEO of Valero Energy. And at the time, Valero Energy was the largest refinery in the US. If you had to think of a crisis that he had to deal with, what would it be? It wasn’t called a crisis at the time, but that was in 2008 when Tesla launched its first electric vehicle. And the Roadster really pioneered the concept of a commercial electric vehicle. At the time, many people dismissed the Roadster as a gimmick. They didn’t believe that electric vehicles would work. Today we know that’s wrong. Electric vehicles are very successful. You now have companies like Tesla, but also BYD in China, for example, selling more of these vehicles around the world, which means that the demand for diesel and gasoline is going down. And that is a crisis for the oil and gas sector. Let’s move on to the next one. This is Ben van Beurden, the former CEO of Shell, in the late 2010s and early 2020s. What would have been its biggest crisis at the time? That one is easy because that’s something that we all went through. This is the pandemic. Due to the pandemic, no one was allowed to drive, no one was allowed to fly, which means that oil and gas companies were unable to sell their products. And that led to record losses for many oil and gas companies. So Shell here that you can see on the screen. Let’s move on to a different industry. This one is a chemical industry. And now we have Martin Brudermüller, the former CEO of BASF. He was a CEO for six years in the late 2010s and early 2020s. Outside of the COVID pandemic, what else did he have to deal with? For him, it was the Russian invasion of Ukraine. When Russia invaded Ukraine, one of the results is that the price of natural gas spike and today remains highly elevated in Europe. And the chemical sector is the one suffering the most today because the chemical sector is highly sensitive to energy prices. And today in Europe, you have many facilities shutting down their operations because they are unable to compete versus facilities, especially in China and in the US. So if we move out of Europe, we now have Mr. Sultan Al Jaber, the CEO of ADNOC. He had to go through many crises. He’s currently going through one right now in the Middle East. But if you had to think of someone that really bothered him during this time, who would it be? Well, it could be Frans Timmermans. Frans Timmermans is a very famous Dutch politician, but he was also the EVP for the EU Green Deal. I don’t know if Sultan Al Jaber had a personal issue with Frans Timmermans himself. But it suddenly took issue with the concept of the EU Green Deal, because the EU Green Deal laid the groundwork for carbon neutrality in Europe, but was also the catalyst for carbon neutrality pledges for many countries around the world, and a carbon neutral world means less oil and gas, and that’s a problem for a company like ADNOC, for example. And it’s also hard to talk about Middle East without talking about the current crisis happening now, where Aramco is suffering a lot today because Aramco is producing its oil but is unable to export it to many of its customers around the world because of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. So what you can see is that throughout history, oil and gas companies have always gone through crisis. And while the crisis is different, it can be a pandemic, it can be a war, it can be new technology, the impact of this crisis is always going to be very similar. And this is what Cansu will tell you more about.

Cansu Doganay: The traps that Runeel has walked us through so far actually fall into four main categories. So loss of feedstock, which is what we are currently experiencing with the US-Iran conflict, loss of cheap energy. So Europe has had very expensive gas prices after the Russian invasion of Ukraine, loss of market, which is what we have experienced, with EVs, with the launch of EVs, and loss of license, which could be the potential impact of the EU Green Deal and decarbonization pledges. And these, these threats are already impacting a lot of the companies around the world. And the question really is how companies react when one or several of these threats hit their business. So the immediate response is to usually go into survival mode, securing supplies, cutting costs, finding ways to keep the operations running. But this survival mode cannot last forever. Eventually, you will reach a decision point. At this point, do you retreat and decommission your assets? Or do you transform the business so it can thrive? And for the rest of the presentation, we would like to focus on the second pathway. So what this transformation could look like and which technologies can help you get there. And to do this, we would like to introduce the Lux resiliency framework.

Runeel Daliah: So what is a Lux resiliency framework? It’s a simple way to visualize how technologies can help you overcome the threats. In the oil and gas and the refinery sector, what are the four main threats? These are the loss of market, loss of feedstock, loss of cheap energy, and loss of your license to operate. What we did here at Lux look at how technology can help you overcome these threats. However, we did not look at individual technologies because there are thousands of them out there, but rather we grouped technologies according to the function that they enable. And you can see the technologies here. Biorefining, electro refining, electrification, and so on. Essentially what these are, these are categories of families of technologies that can help you overcome one or more of these threats. Over the next 30 minutes or so, Cansu and I will be looking at each of these categories and how they can help you address these threats, starting with biorefining. What is biorefining? Biorefining is about replacing your crude oil with a bio-based feedstock, for example, bio oil. How does it help you overcome a threat? Obviously, it’s very simple. If you replace crude oil with bio oil, then you essentially address your loss of feedstock. If, for example, you don’t have access to crude oil anymore because of a war somewhere else around the world, you can replace that lost crude oil with a bio-based feedstock. But because the bio-based feedstock is also renewable, low carbon, it also helps you address your loss of license to operate if, for example, you’re in a region that has very high carbon taxes. But also, it can help you address a loss of market. For example, in the EU, you now have the sustainable aviation fuel mandate, which means that the airline sector has to adopt increasing amount of bio-based fuel. And that mandate is a destruction of demand for fossil jet fuel, for fossil fuel. So as a refiner, you can overcome that loss by switching your product from fossil fuel to sustainable aviation fuel. But biorefining itself is not a technology, but rather a collection of technologies, as you can see here. Here you have various technologies that will allow you to produce a bio-based fuel. You have technologies of all range of development, from lab scale to the commercial scale. And you can see here that you have a range of technologies. We’re not saying here that you should deploy all of these technologies at the same time, because you can’t. Many of these technologies are mutually exclusive. But these are the options you have in order for you to start producing a biobase fuel. These technologies span a wide range of development, and some of them are already at the commercial stage and already being deployed by oil and gas companies. Two of them are co-processing and plastic pyrolysis. These are commercial technologies that are already deployed by oil and gas companies. Two examples here. BP and ExxonMobil. BP in 2018 launched its first co-processing trial at its refinery in the US. It started in 2018 and later expanded the capacity in 2024. Similarly, also in the US, Exxon launched its first plastic pyrolysis facility in 2022, expanded the facility in ’25 and looked into further expand by 2026. So you can see that there are many other examples around the world, but you can see that you already have oil and gas companies deploying these technologies. So it’s very commercial. However, there is a barrier, there is a limitation, and that is about feedstock availability. Because if you look at BP at the last line here, you can see that despite BP having run this project for almost 10 years, the reality is that the co-processing is only equivalent to 3% of the total facility throughput. So why isn’t BP or even Exxon struggling to scale is really because of the lack of feedstock. And this is a big problem in Europe because you can see here the availability of the consumption of waste oil and plastic waste. In the case of waste oil feedstock, Today the EU is using around 1 million ton of waste oil feedstock, mostly to produce sustainable aviation fuel. But you can see that 85% of that waste oil is actually being imported. And today it’s imported mostly from China and from Malaysia, which means that by switching from fossil crude oil to waste oil, the EU has switched its dependency from crude oil from, say, the Middle East to waste oil from China and Malaysia. And that is a risky move. In the case of plastic waste, today the EU is recycling only 30% of its plastic waste. But even in the ideal scenario where the EU were to recycle 100% of its plastic waste, 32 million tons of plastic would lead to pyrolysis oil that is enough for only about 10 to 15% of the EU’s annual consumption of fossil fuel. So you can see that even if those technologies are commercial, they are still limited by the feedstock availability. So what’s the solution? The solution is new technologies that help you unlock novel feedstocks. Technologies on the lab and the pilot scale that you can see here are all currently in development and they allow you to expand your feedstock. For example, technologies like gasification and liquefaction and so on allow you to utilize solid biomass. It also has synthetic biology which allows you to convert sugars or CO2 into your hydrocarbon product. And that’s the one that I want to focus on today. What is synthetic biology? Synthetic biology is about the genetic engineering of microbes to create new production pathways for hydrocarbon fuels and chemicals. Today, LanzaTech is a leader in the space, already at scale with the facilities in China. But most of the startups, most of the companies today are still currently at the lab and bench scale. Today there’s a lot of innovation and a new approach is really the cell-free manufacturing and hybrid approaches which allows for greater control and greater sensitivity to the production of these fuels and chemicals. One big challenge that companies face when they’re looking to enter this space is how to find the right partner, how to find the right startup in order to partner and collaborate with. At Lux, we have designed the Lux innovation grid that you can see here. The Lux innovation grid is essentially a tool that allows people, that allows clients to quickly assess a startup based on its technical value and its business execution. At Lux, we speak with thousands of startups across all technologies and we assess the company based on the technology and the business strategy. And you can see the result here. When we show this figure to people, the first instinct is to say, I want to work with the leaders. I want to work with Virginia with a solution. These are great companies, but that would be the wrong approach because these companies are leaders because they already have a strong technology, but also everything they need in order to go to the market, which is money and commercial partners. If you’re looking to enter the space, the better approach is to assess and partner companies in the green zone here because these are companies that have very good technology that are struggling to scale because they don’t have the money or they don’t have the right commercial partners. And this is really where you can enter the space and help them go to that leadership position. So this is a Lux innovation grid, which we’re showing you here for synthetic biology, but we also have that for every technology, which is hundreds and hundreds of technologies that Lux Research covers. And now moving on to the next category, which is electro refining.

Cansu Doganay: Electro refining is about replacing some of your thermochemical processes. with electrochemical ones. So as you can imagine, it opens up different production routes that use water, CO2, and renewable electricity. So you are less dependent on the crude oil feedstock. But it also enables the production of synthetic fuels, so low carbon fuels. So it also helps you mitigate the risk of loss of market for fossil fuels, as well as your loss of license to operate associated with oil products. What does this technology portfolio look like? So it includes several technologies, several electrochemical technologies, as well as thermochemical ones, because some of the technologies here, for example, an early stage one like CO2 electrolysis can provide syngas from CO2 and water, but it won’t give you a finished fuel or chemical. So you would have to pair it with a Fischer-Tropsch reactor to have a finished product. But as you can see, there are some emerging early stage technologies, but you don’t have to wait for an entire production route to mature because we have some technologies like alkaline and PEM, which are ready for deployment today and can already be integrated into your existing gas networks at your refinery. So this is actually what Shell is trying to do in Germany. They have already deployed a 10 megawatt PEM electrolysis system in 2021. And the idea is, of course, to replace some of its gray hydrogen with green hydrogen from water electrolysis. And as you can see, this project is in Germany, so there’s also a regulatory pressure to integrate renewable hydrogen into the refineries because the German government has already passed, legislated the RFNBO requirements for the transportation sector. But when it comes to electrochemical processes, Electricity costs, the price of electricity can be a major barrier, especially in the EU. Here you can see that the price of electricity ranges from 60 to over 100 EUR per megawatt-hour. And with these electricity prices, even in an optimistic scenario, you will produce hydrogen at about $5 per kilogram. of hydrogen. So this is going to be at least three times more expensive than your gray hydrogen. So if you still want to produce hydrogen in the EU and you have these electricity prices, what you can do is to reduce the amount of electricity needed to produce a kilogram of hydrogen. And this is what the next generation electrolyzers are trying to do. And one emerging approach that we have been monitoring is decoupled electrolysis. So how does it work? In conventional electrolyzers, hydrogen and oxygen evolve at the same time in the same reactor. But, they’re separated by either a separator or a membrane. But in decoupled electrolyzers, the production of hydrogen and oxygen are decoupled. So they’re separated in time and in space or both. So it allows for hydrogen production to operate independently from oxygen evolution. And the separation of these gas evolutions also prevents hydrogen and oxygen from mixing. So it also improves the operational safety. And we have been tracking these innovations for a long time now. And this analysis shows you how these improvements that we have talked about translate into hydrogen production costs. For the second generation that you see here, which also includes decoupled electrolysis, our analysis show that potential savings in the cost of electricity could go up to 10%. With the third generation, even, this is where concepts like electricity-free systems exist. So with these kind of systems, you can even save about 70% in your cost of electricity. And this efficiency, this higher efficiency can also reduce the CapEx contribution per kilogram of hydrogen. So the value of efficiency also extends beyond the cost of electricity. And with that, we would like to move on to the third technology category.

Runeel Daliah: So the third category is about electrification. That’s different from electro refining. Electro refining is about making products from electricity. Electrification is really about tackling your energy consumption. Today, whether you’re an oil and gas or a chemical or a steel company or a cement company, for example, your temperature, your process temperatures are very high temperature processes, above 600, 700, 800 degrees Celsius, some cases even above 1000 degrees Celsius. And today, the industrial sector is reliant on natural gas combustion to reach those high temperatures, but that’s not very helpful if your supply of natural gas is disrupted like it is today in Europe. So electrification is really about swapping natural gas with electricity, where here you would use electricity directly to reach those very high temperatures. Of course, it helps you address the loss of cheap energy, the loss of cheap natural gas. But if you use renewable electricity, it also helps you address the loss of license due to decarbonization requirements. What is a technology portfolio for electrification? It’s a very broad range of technologies, and we can see some of them here. This is essentially any technology that allows you to produce electricity, to store electricity, and also to use electricity directly to generate at high temperature heat. In the case of an oil and gas sector, one very interesting option is electric cracking, and some oil and gas companies have already started exploring this option. And one such example is a collaboration between SABIC, Linde, and BASF. The three companies have partnered and launched a pilot-scale e-cracking facility in Germany in 2024. When you look at naphtha cracking, today it’s a high temperature process. So you crack naphtha into ethylene at more than 800 degrees Celsius. And today around the world, that process is powered with natural gas combustion. In this project, the three companies are shown that they can use electricity to reach those very high temperatures, essentially eliminating natural gas from the production process. This facility, this pilot facility, was launched in 2024, and Linde has practically taken ownership of the facility. They call the technology SPYRO, and they’re now offering this technology to any customer willing to deploy this. Even though Linde has said that the technology is ready to scale, they haven’t yet secured a customer. And why is that? you can already guess the answer because Cansu showed it earlier, it’s because of electricity. But electricity is not just very expensive but also very hard to secure. In the EU, for example, the wait times for securing a grid connection is anywhere from 2 to 10 years. In most countries, it’s at the higher range of that, higher extreme of that range. So it’s not just about getting cheap electricity, but also about getting that connection to the grid. Because if you’re electrifying an industrial process, you need a large amount of electricity. So if you cannot get access to the grid, how about generating your own electricity? If you look at a technology portfolio here, you can see a couple of options. The more commercial option is biomass combustion. Biomass combustion is a very commercial technology, but not really feasible for the industrial sector. Because if you’re a refinery, for example, you don’t have a lot of space to store solid biomass on site, what you want is a technology that has a very high energy density. And this is where small modular reactors, so nuclear option, becomes interesting. Nuclear options, so small modular reactors, sorry, are currently at the lab scale today. but that hasn’t stopped companies from assessing the viability of this technology for their operations. And one such company here is Dow in the US. Dow is a chemical company, and in 2023, they partnered with X Energy to explore the feasibility of deploying SMRs at their facility. There is currently still an agreement. They file for a construction permit in 2025. They expect to have a final decision by end of 2026, end of this year. But even if they do agree to move forward, the technology is currently at the early stage, and you should not expect a commercial system to be up and running anytime soon. The question is, is that the right approach for a company like Dow? At Lux, we’ve done a very comprehensive technical analysis of both large and small modular reactors. And we also look at, based on the result analysis, we look at different application and identify the best fit application for these technologies. Dow Chemical, they would fall into the second category here, which is industrial heating. You can see that SMRs are actually a very poor fit for a chemical company like Dow Chemicals, because here you do not want to deploy an SMR unit to power a single facility. Where SMR really shines is cogeneration for industrial clusters. With here, you would build an SMR and sell both electricity and the heat to a range of refineries, chemical facilities, and so on, to essentially de-risk the entire operation. Even though it’s the most suitable fit, doesn’t mean that it will be used, because again, SMR technology is currently at a very early stage. And even if you were to say build one today, you will not be online until after 2035 and after 2040. So you will be waiting a very long time for this. So it’s important technology to monitor, but not, I would say, the solution for replacing natural gas with electricity. So moving on to the next category, which is carbon management.

Cansu Doganay: With carbon management, we have routes that offer, emission reduction. So this is only a way to address, so sorry, carbon management is capable of addressing the loss of license threats only because it just is for emission abatement. And within this category, as you can imagine, we have included various capture technologies, sequestration, as well as carbon offsetting like DAC and direct air capture and direct ocean capture. And most of these capture technologies are at scale with several companies offering a technology today. So most of these are, as you can imagine, are ready for deployment. And today we see oil and gas activity mostly in solvent-based capture with enhanced oil recovery. So a good example to this is Sinopec. Between 2021 and 2023, they have deployed 3 carbon capture projects using Nanjing’s chemicals solvent. So this is a way of leveraging a near-term opportunity for oil and gas companies because with these kind of projects, with carbon capture and enhanced oil recovery, oil and gas companies can leverage their expertise in gas handling, CO2 handling, as well as subsurface operations. But carbon capture has a bad reputation for being expensive. Even with a mature technology like solvents, for example, energy consumption can go up to about 4 gigajoules per ton of CO2 capture. And most of this energy is required to regenerate the solvent, so to release this CO2. So if you can avoid this step, it could lead to a significant cost reduction. And that’s the idea behind reactive carbon capture. So This pathway, this technology aims to bypass the separate CO2 release step so that you bridge carbon capture and conversion together. So what you do here is you convert the CO2 into chemicals or fuels or syngas while they still dissolve in its carbon capture medium. As you can see, this is a very early-stage technology, so it’s still at the lab scale today. But there are a handful of startups already involved in technology development. And we have spoken to several of these, including sort of few. And we have assessed them across several metrics. after the conversation. And as you can see, Sorofuel has scored very well on its technology value, meaning that it has a promising technology because with reactive carbon capture, you can save up to around 18% for point source capture. and up to 30% for DAC compared to the sequential capture and conversion. But if you also look at some of the red scores here, which are IP and partnerships, the company still has, still needs time and partners to scale the technology. So if you remember the innovation grid, Lux Innovation Grid that Runeel showed us earlier, we would place somewhere in the high potential quadrant. So that makes it a company to partner with because the technology has a promising value proposition but needs partners. So this is an opportunity for the people that are joining us today to help bring it to scale.

Runeel Daliah: So the next category is about efficiency. Typically when we talk about efficiency, we don’t really talk about breakthrough technologies. This is usually where you would have it in carbon capture, electro refining and so on. But that doesn’t mean that efficiency is not important. It’s actually quite important because you can see here on the slide is that Efficiency is one of the few categories that actually help you address your loss of cheap energy. For example, if your energy bills becomes very high, efficiency is about reducing energy consumption, reduce consumption, reduce your energy costs. But also, given that today energy is coming from natural gas, reduction in natural gas consumption also leads to reduction in emissions. It also helps you address the loss of license due to decarbonization requirements. Efficiency is not a technology, but rather a collection of different technologies that allow you to be more efficient. And there are so many technologies out there that we don’t have the space to include them all, but we wanted to look at the main categories, which are sensors and separations, because these two are very important to the oil and gas sector. Both technologies are currently very much commercial, and there’s many deployments in the oil and gas sector. And I would say two core approaches for oil and gas is electromagnetic sensing and distillation for separations. It’s very commercial. Many examples are there. The two that I want to call out is one by Tracerco and Sulzer. In the case of sensors, Tracerco is one of the leaders in its sensor technology for oil and gas projects is core technology to scan, uses a gamma ray sensors to essentially generate A one-dimensional image of a reactor. You don’t need to open the reactor to see what’s going on. Through the technology, you can see any defects in your catalyst bed, for example, which allows you to improve the maintenance of your system. And they’ve been deployed now at many, many facilities for many decades now. In the case of separation, you have Sulzer, which is a leader in the space. So Sulzer, one of these key technologies is the VGPlus technology, which is an advanced distillation separation in order to separate propane from propylene. And that has been deployed in many facilities around the world. Despite these technologies being commercial, it doesn’t mean that they don’t have limitations, because they do. In the case of Tracerco, The image that they provide is great, but it is still a 1D scan, a one-dimensional scan, which means that you do have limited information that you can get from that image. In the case of Sulzer, the technology works great, but at the end of the day, distillation is still energy intensive. And if you’re faced with very high energy bills because of natural gas crisis, then it doesn’t really help you overcome your problem. So this is why innovation is very important because despite distillation and electromagnetic sensing being very commercial, there’s still a need for innovation in order to improve on both approaches. And 2 innovations I want to highlight is force field sensing and facilitated transport membranes. Force field sensing, one of the key companies here is GScan. GScan, they have a very different approach. They use naturally occurring cosmic ray particles in order to generate a 3D image of a system, not 1D, but 3D. And as you can imagine, if you have a three-dimensional image, you get even better view of the inside of your reactor system. Today, GScan is not yet deployed at an oil and gas facility. The technology has been tested for large infrastructure projects, for example, bridges, for example. But the company is looking to enter the oil and gas space and the chemical space. In the case of membranes, a very good example is Braskem. Braskem partnered with Arden, a startup that is developing a silver-based membrane in order to selectively separate olefins from paraffins. Unlike distillation, which is a very energy-intensive process, membrane is quite straightforward. It’s just an absorption process. So this is already deployed at the Braskem facility, has been testing this technology now for over 10,000 hours, and Arden claimed that with their membranes you can increase the yield of polyolefin by up to 8%, which leads to a saving of 5 to 8 million. So yes, we can see that despite efficiency technologies being very commercial, you do have potential for innovation and for improvement in the space. So moving on to the last category, which is also the most interesting one, and Cansu will tell you more about this.

Cansu Doganay: Until now, what we have discussed really focused on adapting how existing products are made. But product flexibility goes a step further. So it helps you expand the portfolio beyond conventional oil products. So your business is less dependent on one single market. There are several technologies that can support this diversification, but there are different stages of deployment and maturity. So the ones that are commercially available are mostly petrochemicals and We have seen deployments when it comes to thermal pathway here. So it allows for companies to direct more of the value of the crude oil towards petrochemicals. So one company that is pursuing this is S-Oil. They’re using Aramco’s technology to expand the production of ethylene and propylene from crude oil. So the logic behind this is to diversify into petrochemicals as the outlook for petrochemicals, sorry, as the outlook for transportation fuels change. But entering a new market doesn’t automatically remove the market risk. You also need to consider how attractive that market will be when your capacity becomes online. And for ethylene, the production capacity has been growing faster than the demand. And this, as you can see, led to a growing overcapacity in the last decade. So this really puts pressure on utilization and margins, which makes it harder to justify the additional capacity unless you have a clear cost or market advantage. So we talked about petrochemicals, which is one option that you can pursue, but it’s not the only option. As an oil and gas company, you bring expertise in extraction, exploration, gas conversion. So this can support your entry into critical minerals. And there are various technologies that can help you enter that market. Today we’re already seeing some oil and gas activity by Exxon and by Occidential. So Exxon, for example, announced a partnership with BASF to develop a methane pyrolysis facility in Texas. And before this announcement, Exxon also acquired a graphitization technology provider, Superior Graphite. So these two announcements, back-to-back, actually signals that Exxon might be considering to upgrade the pyrolysis carbon into graphite. And Oxy is pursuing a different critical mineral. Through its partnership with BHE Renewables, they will extract lithium from geothermal brands using adsorbents. So these are two different technologies, but this is, they still offer, a way for these companies to apply their capabilities, industrial capabilities, to a new market. But, what’s interesting is that neither of the, neither opportunity is simply, a response to an immediate supply shortage. Our supply and demand analysis, for example, for graphite, show that the supply of graphite will actually exceed the demand by 2035. And currently, lithium is experiencing, is facing a period of supply surplus. So why are these two oil majors entering the space now? And the answer is supply chain security. For example, China dominates graphite supply as well as lithium refining. So even when the global supply is sufficient, this concentration of supply, this China dominance can actually leave customers exposed to trade restrictions. And these materials are essential for EV batteries, electrode and semiconductor manufacturing. So the opportunity here is about more than the market growth for these minerals. It’s really about building a supply chain in areas where of these companies can bring their expertise in. And with that, we have walked you through all the technology categories and shown where companies are investing today, what their challenges are, and what emerging solutions they can pursue. So this framework really gives you a way to connect a threat to a response. But what it does not help you do is to predict the next crisis. And actually, there is no tool or a framework that can help you predict what’s next. This timeline here shows you how different these crises, these disruptions can be. Over the last five to six years, we have seen that the EU has gone through several wars, pandemics. So all of this came after the EU Green Deal was announced, which actually changed the regulatory landscape for the local businesses in the EU. Even though these crisis were very difficult to predict, what you can do is to predict what its impact will be, because a single event can also trigger several of these threats at once. So what you can do is to assess. your exposure to each threat and identify the responses you could put in place.

Runeel Daliah: And this is really what it’s about at the end of the day. It’s really about assessing your exposure to the crisis. You can’t predict it, but you can prepare for it. This is something that I would say the EU has not been very good at when it comes to preparation, because if you go back in time, let’s say five or seven years back in time. What would have been the biggest crisis that facing the industrial sector in Europe? It probably would have been the EU Green Deal. I wouldn’t call the Green Deal itself a crisis. It’s not. It is needed. However, the impact of it is quite significant because a lot of the European industry is reliant on fossil fuel for their operations and now they have to phase it all out. in order to meet the target of the EU Green Deal. But you can see that for the European sector, they weren’t too worried, because if you look at the options that can help you address the loss of license due to decarbonization, you have quite a lot. And that’s the reason why over the next year or two, many industries, whether oil and gas and so on, were announcing all of these decarbonization projects. You had oil and gas companies looking to build biofuel facilities, the steel sector with hydrogen, the fertilizer sector with green ammonia, the chemical sector with methanol. So all of these projects were announced in order to address the demand of the EU Green Deal. However, just two years later, you now have a new crisis, which is the high natural gas prices caused by the Russian invasion of Ukraine. And you can see here that some of the solutions that can help you address decarbonization do nothing to help you address the increase in electricity in the energy process. For example, if you take bio-refining, for example, it’s a great technology for decarbonization, replaces crude oil with bio-based feedstock. But at the end of the day, bio-refining is still an energy-intensive process that still relies, that would still rely on natural gas. And if natural gas prices go up, then biorefining is not viable anymore. Same with carbon capture. Capture is very energy intensive, so great for decarbonization, but not so good when your energy is very expensive. So you can see that just two, three years after you have a new crisis and that unfortunately led to the cancellation of many of these projects. We’re not here to say that There’s no future in low carbon projects because that’s not true at all. There are still many low carbon projects in Europe and around the world that are still moving forward. However, what we want to highlight here is the danger of building the business case of your project solely relying on its ability to address a single crisis. Because at the other day, crises will come. You cannot predict what they are, but you can predict what the impact will be. So it’s very important when you build a project, whether it’s bankable or not, to really assess the viability of the project under different crisis scenarios, because this is how the project will remain up and standing.

Cansu Doganay: And when it comes to technology, technology development, as Runeel mentioned, you should be targeting to solve more than one threat. Because if you only target one threat or one solution, you probably, you have less chance of succeeding in the market because the market is very unpredictable and has a lot of uncertainties. And we are already seeing some of the low carbon technologies, value proposition shift today. If we were considering methane pyrolysis projects a couple of years ago, like 5, six years ago, we will be promoting it for low carbon hydrogen production. and green ammonia would be the same. We would be considering to use it to decarbonize fertilizer production. But what is happening today is that, for example, methane pyrolysis is positioned as an alternative graphite supply route. And similarly, what we are seeing with green ammonia is that it is being pursued in several regions to ensure food security. So they are focusing on building local supply chains so that you are not impacted when the fertilizer imports from the Middle East is disrupted. So with that, We would like to thank you for your attention, and we can take any questions from the audience.

Runeel Daliah: Absolutely. Thank you very much. And as a chance to say, we will be taking questions that you have on the presentation, which you can type in the question box. And I see that a few questions are already coming in as well. I would say that given the time, because it’s already almost at the hour, we’ll probably take one question. And looking at the ones that came in, there’s quite a number of questions around costs. So, what I can do is that I can, combine these questions all together because it’s on the same topic. But I would say, perhaps I can answer the question. When it comes to the framework, the framework helps you address how to overcome threats. It presents technologies to help you overcome threats. But what it doesn’t do, and I do agree the question here, is that what it doesn’t do is show you the cost of doing so. Because the framework doesn’t talk about the costs of deploying this technology. So for example, deploying a new sensor is much cheaper than deploying an entire new biorefinery, even though they address the same threats. So why wasn’t cost included in this assessment? Can you shed a bit more light on this?

Cansu Doganay: That’s a great question. And I also agree. Cost is a big barrier when it comes to most of these technologies that we discussed. And the reason why we didn’t include is because cost is a very company and site specific. So it will vary depending on the type of the company, whether it’s oil and gas, steel or chemicals, the size of the operation, customer base, and most importantly, geographic location. So for example, biorefining is a great option if you have access to feedstock. But for many companies, for many regions, This feedstock bottleneck eliminates the option, even if it’s the cheapest option. So what we recommend is that you generate your own resiliency framework according to your business needs and then assess the cost of technology, but also the cost of adoption into your assessment. So, and we can help you do so at Lux because we have all the technoeconomic details of the technologies that we have shown you today. So please always, feel free to reach out if you would like us to help you on this assessment.

Runeel Daliah: Great. There’s a few more questions that came in as well, but I’m looking at the time here. Unfortunately, we’re already at 50 minutes. It’s been quite a long session already. So what we will do is that we will reach out back to you and answer your questions. And for those of you who haven’t got a chance to answer questions, we can put your question in the question box and we promise that we will reach back out to you. But for now, this concludes the session for today. The slide presentation and the recording from this session will be sent to all the attendees via e-mail today. And after leaving the webinar, you will be asked to complete a survey of today’s presentation. And we would really appreciate any feedback, negative and positive, that you have, and that really helps us inform and improve our future webinars. But for now, thank you very much for joining us, and have a great day, everyone. Thank you.

Benchmark Your Innovation Investment

Get an executive framework for benchmarking innovation investment and preparing for 2027.

What do you want to research today?